Employment law

Hume v Gathuku [2026] KEELRC 15027 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Appeal E208 of 2023
Judgment date
6 November 2026
Judge(s)
Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 16th October, 2023, the Appellant appeals against the part of the Judgment of Honourable Lucy Njora, CM delivered on 18th September, 2023 on grounds inter alia that: -

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

This court has in a number of times pronounced itself on issues of absconding of duties by an employee with recently the court in the case of Owudu v Digital Sanitation Services Limited (Appeal E109 of 2023) [2024] KEELRC 917 (KLR) (18 April 2024) (Judgment) holding as follows:-

Paragraph 19 →

Reasoning passage

This court is of the view that in as much as the Respondent had a duty under section 47(5) of the Employment Act to prove that termination occurred this court finds that the Respondent illustrated that the termination had occurred and the burden shifted to the Appellant to illustrate that the reasons for the termination were fair under the said provision more so when a defence of desertion is raised by the employer it is its duty to…

Paragraph 15 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

APPEALS DIVISION

APPEAL NO. E208 OF 2023

AGATHE MARIE HUME ……………………………………..APPELLANT

VERSUS

AGNES KIRIGO GATHUKU…..……………….…………. RESPONDENT

(Being an appeal arising from the Judgment of Honourable Lucy Njora, CM delivered at Milimani Chief Magistrates Court in CMELRC No. E775 of 2020 on 18th Day of September, 2023)

JUDGMENT

(Before Hon. Justice Abuodha Jorum Nelson)

1. Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 16th October, 2023, the Appellant appeals against the part of the Judgment of Honourable Lucy Njora, CM delivered on 18th September, 2023 on grounds inter alia that: -

i. The Honourable Court erred in both law and fact by finding that Claimant’s dismissal was unlawful, as there is no basis or supporting evidence adduced to support such a determination.

ii. The Honourable Court erred in law by awarding the Respondent one month in lieu of notice, despite the absence of evidence indicating that the Appellant wrongfully terminated the Respondent’s employment contract.

iii. The Honourable Court erred in law by awarding compensation for unfair termination, despite the lack of substantial evidence demonstrating that the respondent’s termination from employment was unfair.

iv. The Honourable Court erred in law by awarding a service charge when there was insufficient evidence to justify the termination of the respondent was unfair.

v. The Honourable Court erred in law by granting unpaid leave to the Respondent, even though there is overwhelming evidence indicating that the Respondent already received paid leave on an annual basis.

vi. The Honourable Court erred in law by awarding salary for November 2019, despite the fact that the Claimant has admitted to having received this salary for the month.

2. The Appellant therefore prayed that the Appeal be allowed with costs and the judgment against the Appellant and all subsequent orders in Milimani Chief Magistrate Court, ELRC E775 of 2020 be set aside and be substituted with an order dismissing the suit against the Appellant.

3. The Appeal was disposed of by written submissions.

APPELLANT’S SUBMISSIONS

4. The Appellant’s Advocates Owino Kojo and Company Advocates filed written submissions dated 13th March, 2026 and submitted among others that:-

i. On grounds 1, 3 and 4 on the finding on unlawful and unfair termination counsel relied on Section 107 of the Evidence Act which places the burden of a party who alleges to prove the existence of the fact. That the record of the trial court confirms that at no point did the Respondent ever prove that her employment was terminated. At cross examination, she confirmed that she had no proof that the Appellant terminated her employment.

ii. Counsel submitted that the Appellant on the other hand proved that the Respondent stopped going to work without any notice or explanation. The Appellant’s witness also corroborated the foregoing testimony by stating that the Respondent “was not fired from employment.”

iii. It was submitted that the Appellant made it very clear that she did not terminate the Respondent’s employment as alleged. She proved that the Respondent simply failed to report to work from 25.11.2019. The Respondent did not produce any evidence to show that her employment was terminated. The trial court therefore erred in awarding the Respondent 6 months’ compensation yet the Appellant did not terminate the Respondent’s employment.

iv. Counsel submitted that under section 49(4)(b) of the Employment Act, as read together with section 50 therein, the Court is under an obligation to consider “the circumstances in which the termination took place, including the extent, if any, to which the employee caused or contributed to the termination.”

v. It was submitted that the Employment Act provides for remedies for unfair termination but not for an employee who decides to stop her engagement with the employer at will and without notice. The Respondent alleged that her employment contract was unfairly terminated and the trial court held in her favour based on the wrong premise that the Respondent’s employment was terminated. Given that the Appellant did not terminate the Respondent’s employment, counsel concluded that the trial Court erred in its finding that there was unlawful and unfair termination.

vi. It was further submitted that having found that the Respondent secured another job, the court should have concluded that she left the Appellant’s employment in order to secure another job. The trial court should not therefore have proceeded to award the Respondent Kshs. 180,000 as compensation for unfair dismissal.

vii. On ground number 2 on payment in lieu of notice counsel submitted that having proved that the Appellant did not terminate the Respondent’s employment and that the Respondent simply deserted service, it was therefore wrong for the trial court to award her Kshs. 30,000 as ‘one month pay in lieu of notice.’ The Appellant could not issue any notice to the Respondent since she did not intend to terminate her employment and she could not reasonably foresee her untimely desertion of duty.

viii. On ground number 5 on unpaid leave counsel submitted that the Respondent claimed Kshs.180,000 for unpaid leave for six years, commencing 27.03.2013. The suit in the trial court was filed on 10.09.2020 which implies that any claim which accrued more than 3 years before filing, i.e. on or before 10.09.2017, are time barred. Counsel relied on section 90 of the Employment Act on this assertion. That the trial court was therefore wrong in awarding the Respondent Kshs. 180,000 as damages for unpaid leave for 6 years.

ix. Further counsel submitted that the Appellant proved that the Respondent enjoyed paid leave for at least 1 month every year whenever the Appellant travelled abroad with her family, which was and still is a ritual for the Appellant’s family. This fact was admitted by the Respondent.

x. It was submitted that the Appellant’s testimony agreed with that of the Respondent and confirmed that the Respondent did not only go on leave for at least 1 month every year but sometimes for 2 months, and was paid during those days. This proves that the Appellant did not only comply with the law but was also humane in her dealings with the Respondent.

xi. Counsel submitted that the Appellant’s witness also corroborated the foregoing testimonies by stating that the annual leave would last for up to 65 days in some years. He also confirmed that they locked the door during the said period for security reasons. The trial court therefore erred in its finding that the appellant “has no evidence ... proving the Claimant [now Respondent] used to proceed on leave as required by law.” This finding therefore contradicts the foregoing testimonies of all the witnesses as well as documents produced including the travel documents by the Appellant and her family.

xii. Counsel submitted that the Respondent’s argument that she continued to work in the absence of the Appellant’s family cannot hold given that she was employed to provide nanny services which she could not provide for at least 1 month every year whenever the Appellant travelled abroad with her children.

xiii. On ground number 6 on November 2019 salary counsel submitted that the Honourable Court erred in law by awarding the Respondent salary for November 2019, despite the fact that she admitted to having received the salary for that month. The Appellant’s witness also corroborated the foregoing testimony by stating that he sent Kshs.20,000 to the Respondent in December 2019. This, in addition to the amount of Kshs. 5,000 paid by the Appellant and admitted by the Respondent, constituted the salary for the 25 days worked in November 2019.

RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS

5. The Respondent’s Advocates Kinyua Mwaniki & Wainaina Advocates filed written submissions dated 9th April, 2026 and submitted among others that:-

i. On grounds 1, 3 and 4 on unlawful and unfair termination counsel submitted that it was necessary to make one preliminary but fundamental observation that the Appellant has throughout these proceedings sought to characterize the Respondent's departure from employment as a desertion or abandonment which characterization is not only factually incorrect but is also legally untenable on the evidence before the trial court.

ii. Counsel submitted that the Appellant alleged that the trial court erred in finding that the Respondent's dismissal was unlawful and that there was no evidence to support this finding. That the Appellant's entire case is built on the assertion that the Respondent failed to prove that she was terminated. This submission fundamentally misconstrues the law and misreads the evidence.

iii. Counsel relied on Section 47(5) of the Employment Act on the respective burdens of proof. That this provision was unambiguous and decisive. Once the Respondent placed before the court her account of the circumstances of her departure, the legal burden shifted squarely to the Appellant to prove that termination was lawful and fair.

iv. That the Respondent gave clear testimony that she reported to work on 25th November 2019 and was told her employment had ended. The Appellant's bare denial that she terminated the Respondent's employment does not discharge the burden of proof imposed upon her by Section 47(5) of the Employment Act. A denial is not evidence.

v. It was submitted that there were no letters, no show-cause notices, no warning letters, no records of attempted communication, and no evidence of any follow-up action whatsoever after the Respondent's alleged absence. Counsel relied on the case of Ronald Nyambu Daudi v Tornado Carriers Limited [2019] KEELRC 2150 (KLR), on desertion of employee.

vi. Counsel submitted that the Appellant presented no evidence whatsoever that she reached out to the Respondent after 25th November 2019. There is no letter of termination, no letter warning of impending termination for desertion, no WhatsApp communication. The silence of the Appellant's own records is itself corroborative of the Respondent's account. An employer who genuinely believed her nanny had deserted would, at the very minimum, have attempted to contact her.

vii. Further counsel submitted that the absence of a written contract of employment operates decisively against the Appellant. Counsel relied on the case of Martin Ireri Ndwiga v Olerai Management Company [2017] KEELRC 424 (KLR), where the court held that where an employer fails to issue an employee with a written contract of service, the word of the employee is to be believed.

viii. It was submitted that the Appellant failed to issue the Respondent with a written contract of service as required by Sections 8, 9 and 10 of the Employment Act. Having failed in this basic statutory obligation, she cannot now be heard to dispute the Respondent's account of the employment relationship, including the circumstances of its termination. The word of the Respondent must be believed. The trial court was therefore entirely correct in finding that termination had occurred.

ix. Counsel further submitted that the Respondent discharged her obligations under Section 47(5) of the Employment Act. The burden then lay on the Appellant to disprove termination a burden she conspicuously failed to discharge.

x. Counsel further submitted that the Appellant failed entirely to comply with the procedural requirements of Section 41 of the Employment Act, as she never gave the Respondent an opportunity to be heard. The Appellant took absolutely no step to comply with Section 41 of the Employment Act. She issued no notice, convened no hearing, and gave the Respondent no opportunity to respond.

xi. Counsel relied on the case of Alphonce Maghanga Mwachanya v Operation 680 Limited [2013] KEHC 3275 (KLR), on adherence to procedural fairness provided for under section 41 of the Act. That none of these steps were taken by the Appellant. The Respondent was neither given reasons for the alleged termination nor afforded any opportunity to be heard. This failure alone renders the termination both substantively and procedurally unfair.

xii. It was submitted that the Appellant's further argument that the trial court should have concluded the Respondent left to secure another job because she subsequently found employment is both speculative and irrelevant. The fact that the Respondent mitigated her loss by obtaining subsequent employment does not retroactively justify the Appellant's unlawful conduct. That it is, if anything, further evidence that the Respondent was suddenly left without employment and was compelled to seek alternative means of livelihood. The trial court's findings on unlawful and unfair termination are therefore well-founded and ought to be upheld.

xiii. On ground 2 on payment in lieu of notice counsel relied on Section 36 of the Employment Act which provides for payment in lieu of notice. That the Respondent was not given any notice of the termination of her employment. She was not given a single day's notice. She was simply told her employment had ended. The Respondent was entitled to this payment as a matter of statutory right and the trial court was correct to award it.

xiv. On ground 5 on unpaid annual leave counsel submitted that the Appellant raises two arguments in respect of unpaid annual leave; first, that some claims especially unpaid leave occurring three years before filing of the claim are time barred; and second, that the Respondent actually enjoyed paid leave when the Appellant's family travelled abroad.

xv. It was submitted that both arguments are without merit. On the limitation argument counsel submitted that it is trite law that a party is bound by its pleadings, and is barred from introducing new issues on appeal. Reliance was placed on the case of Frann Investment Limited v Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission & 6 others [2024] KECA 714 (KLR) on this assertion. That the issue of limitation under Section 90 of the Employment Act was never raised by either party at the hearing in the trial court. Neither did the Appellant plead it in its defense nor did it raise it in submissions before the trial court.

xvi. It was further submitted that the issue was never raised by the trial court suo moto. The trial magistrate made no finding, invitation, or indication that the claim might be time-barred, and the parties were never invited to address the court on limitation.

xvii. On the alleged annual leave during foreign travel counsel submitted that the Appellant's central factual claim is that the Respondent was on paid leave whenever the Appellant's family travelled abroad, allegedly for at least one month and sometimes two months each year. This argument, while cleverly constructed, collapses under scrutiny. The Respondent's evidence was that she continued to work during the periods the Appellant's family was away. She kept and cleaned the house and maintained the property.

xviii. It was submitted that the Appellant's claim that the house was locked and no keys were left with anyone is self-serving and was directly contradicted by the Respondent, who testified that she had keys to the house and continued to attend to it. The Appellant produced travel documents showing the family travelled abroad each year.

xix. It was submitted that the travel documents showing the Appellant and her family were abroad do not, by themselves, prove that the Respondent was on annual leave. They merely prove the family was away. The Appellant failed to produce any leave records, leave application forms, or any documentation confirming that the Respondent had formally been placed on annual leave in any of the years in question. Reliance was placed on the case of Martin Ireri Ndwiga v Olerai Management Company [2017] KEELRC 424 (KLR) on the duty of employer to keep employment records including leave.

xx. That the Appellant produced no such records. The obligation was hers to discharge, and she failed to do so. The trial court's finding that the Appellant had no evidence proving the Respondent went on leave as required by law was therefore well-founded and should not be disturbed.

xxi. On ground 6 on November 2019 salary counsel submitted that the Appellant contends that the Respondent admitted receiving her November 2019 salary, and that the Appellant's witness confirmed sending Kshs. 20,000 via Mpesa in December 2019. The assertion by the Appellant's witness (her husband) that he sent Kshs. 20,000 to the Respondent via Mpesa was unsupported by any documentary evidence. No Mpesa statement was produced in court. No transaction records were exhibited. The trial court was therefore correct to award salary for November 2019. The Appellant cannot rely on an unsubstantiated Mpesa claim to discharge an obligation that required documentary proof.

DETERMINATION

6. The court has considered the grounds of appeal, the record of appeal and submissions filed by the both parties herein and proceeds to analyse them while appreciating the role of this court as to re-evaluate the evidence tendered at trial court and reach its own determination while placing reliance on the case of Court of Appeal for East Africa in Peters –vs- Sunday Post Limited [1958] EA 424 among others.

12. In this case, the judgment of the trial court was that judgment was entered in favour of the Claimant against the Respondent with costs . The trial court found that the termination was unfair and ordered compensation for unfair termination at six months’ salary of Kshs 180,000/=, Notice pay of Kshs 30,000/=, service pay at Kshs 90,000/=, unpaid leave at Kshs 180,000/= and November 2019 salary for 25 days of Kshs 25,000/= .The Appellant appeals on the part of the Judgment fronting 6 grounds of appeal which this court will frame in to two issues which are:-

a. Whether the trial court erred by finding that Respondents’ termination of employment was unfair and unlawful

b. WHEHWWwWhetherWhetherWhe Whether the trial Magistrate erred in awarding the Respondent her terminal dues.

Whether the trial court erred by finding that Respondents’ termination of employment was unfair and unlawful

13. It is not in dispute that the Respondent was employed by the Appellant as a nanny on March 2013 and she worked up to November, 2019 when the parties take diverge positions on how employment ended. Whereas the Respondent alleged that on 25th November, 2019 the Appellant notified her work was over the Appellant alleged that the Respondent stopped coming to work without notice or explanation from 25/11/2019. That she absconded duties and never illustrated if she was terminated by the Appellant.

14. This court notes that the employment relationship herein was oral in nature and the Appellant never reduced the same in to writing as required by the Employment Act under sections 8, 9 and 10. Courts have held that where the employer does not reduce the contract into writing the employees word will be taken as the truth. The courts have always held that for termination to pass fairness test there should be both substantive and procedural fairness. This court refers to the holding in Janet Nyandiko versus Kenya Commercial Bank Limited (2017) eKLR among others.

15. This court is of the view that in as much as the Respondent had a duty under section 47(5) of the Employment Act to prove that termination occurred this court finds that the Respondent illustrated that the termination had occurred and the burden shifted to the Appellant to illustrate that the reasons for the termination were fair under the said provision more so when a defence of desertion is raised by the employer it is its duty to justify this ground.

16. The Appellant alleged that the Respondent deserted her own duties at her own volition and she was not terminated. Under Section 44(4) (a) of the Employment Act 2007, absconding duty by an employee constitutes gross misconduct and renders an employee liable for summary dismissal. The Appellant relied on the defence of desertion that the Respondent had no intention of returning to the place of work.

17. The Appellant had a duty under section 43 and 47(5) of the Act to justify the grounds of termination and demonstrate the reasons were fair and valid which would lead to unfair termination under section 45 of the Act if there was no valid reasons and the procedure followed was unfair.

18. When it comes to desertion the court is well guided by the sentiments in the case of Stanley Omwoyo Onchweri v Board of Management Nakuru YMCA Secondary School [2015] eKLR, where the court held that:-

18. Desertion can only take place where an employee leaves employment with the intention of not returning or formulating such intention not to return after leaving. Such intention may be demonstrated by showing absence of communication from the employee, duration of absence, impact of the absence and nature of employee’s duties.

19. This court has in a number of times pronounced itself on issues of absconding of duties by an employee with recently the court in the case of Owudu v Digital Sanitation Services Limited (Appeal E109 of 2023) [2024] KEELRC 917 (KLR) (18 April 2024) (Judgment) holding as follows:-

17.First, an employee does not terminate his employment in a case of alleged abscondment. When faced with an employee who fails to attend work, the employer must issue notice to the employee to render an account over his misconduct. Where the employee persists and fails to abide by such directions, the employer is required to issue notice terminating employment or summary dismissal through the last known address of the employer.

18.Further, under Section 18(5) (b) of the Act, where the employer cannot trace the employee, notice must be issued to the Labour Officer and any terminal dues deposited in such office. Then, the employer has undertaken its legal duty to properly end employment.

20. In this particular case no notice was issued to the Respondent upon absconding duty or to the labour office and her terminal dues deposited therein. In addition, if the Respondent absconded duties the Appellant did not demonstrate that it commenced any disciplinary action against the Respondent under Section 41 of the Employment Act after she allegedly failed to report on duty.

21. In Joseph Nzioka v Smart Coatings Limited [2017] eKLR Nduma J. observed that

“Dismissal on account of absconding must be preceded by evidence showing that reasonable attempt was made to contact the employer concerned and that a show cause letter was issued to such employee calling upon such employee to show cause why his services should not be terminated on account of absconding duties.”

22. In this present case, the Appellant did not illustrate any efforts of contacting the Respondent to inform her that they were considering terminating her services due to absconding of duties. The court agrees with the trial court that the Appellant did not on a balance of probabilities discharge its onus of establishing that the Respondent absconded/deserted duty. The Appellant did not issue any show cause letter to the Respondent or any hearing before termination hence it also failed on the procedural fairness under section 41. This court agrees with the trial court finding that the Appellant terminated the Respondent’s services unfairly.

Whether the trial Magistrate erred in awarding the Respondent her terminal dues.

23. The trial court having found the termination to be unfair it was justified in awarding damages for unfair termination. On the issue of the trial court awarding the Respondent 6 months’ salary which the Appellant felt was excessive in the circumstances. This court as an appellate court can only interfere with such discretion if there was an error on some matters leading to erroneous decision as was held on the case of Kenya Revenue Authority & 2 others v Darasa Investments Limited (2018) eKLR where the court held;

The court ought not to interfere with the exercise of discretion unless it is satisfied that the Judge misdirected himself in some matter and as a result arrived at a wrong decision, or that it be manifest from the case as a whole that the judge was clearly wrong in the exercise of discretion and occasioned injustice.

24. This court will therefore disturb the awards herein if it is proved that the trial court misdirected itself in some matter hence arriving at a wrong decision. This court notes that the award of compensation is discretionary on the court as provided for under section 49(1)(c ) of the Employment Act with a maximum of 12 months’ salary but the court should be guided by considerations set out under Section 49(4) of the Employment Act in awarding the compensation herein.

25. The court takes note of period of service of 6 years and the nature of termination which was unfair and finds that 6 months was justified and reasonable compensation. The court finds no reason to disturb this award.

26. The award of one-month salary pay in lieu of notice was also justified after finding the Respondent was unfairly terminated without notice as provided for under section 36 of the Employment Act. The Respondent was also entitled to salary for days worked in November 2019 since the Appellant never produced any evidence of the payment of the same. The Respondent was also entitled to service pay although it was not among the grounds of appeal this court will not delve on this claim.

27. On the claim for leave pay this court appreciates that it is continuing injury which the Claimant must file his suit within 12 months after cessation of employment as per section 90 of the Employment Act. This court notes that the employment relationship herein ended in 25th November,2019 and the Claim was filed in August, 2020 which is within 12 months as required. The Appellant improperly construed the above provision to be limited to three years. The right position is that so long as the Claimant filed their claim in 12 months period they are entitled to their continuing injury claims.

28. In among other cases the court of Appeal in G4S Security Services (K) Limited v Joseph Kamau & 468 others [2018] eKLR the court held as follows: -

 Regarding ‘a continuing injury’, the proviso to Section 90 of the Employment Act requires that the claim be made within 12 months next after the cessation thereof. The learned Judge did not determine when the continuing injury ceased, for purposes of computing the twelve month period. In the absence of a defined period, the learned Judge erred in concluding that the claims had no limitation of time. Further, upon the claimant’s dismissal, any claim based on a continuing injury ought to have been filed within one year failing which it was time barred.

29. This court appreciates that leave is an entitlement for an employee under section 28 of the Employment Act. The Appellant as the custodian of employment records under section 74 ought to have produced records showing the Respondent proceeded on leave. Failure to tender such evidence leads to the conclusion that the Respondent was entitled to the said leave.

30. The Appellant produced travel documents showing the family would travel abroad for one or two months every year and they would allow the Respondent proceed on her leave that period. That they would lock the house for security reasons. The Respondent on the other hand alleged that she had the house keys and she would clean and manage the property while the family was away.

31. In the upshot the Appeal is found unmerited and is hereby dismissed with costs to the Respondent.

32. It is so ordered.

Dated at Nairobi this 6th day of November, 2026

Delivered virtually this 6th day of November, 2026

Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Presiding Judge-Appeals Division

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder